I have a Napster account. I pay monthly and I can download unlimited songs (thats what they say).
At first I loved the service. I got a free MP3 player of marginal quality and the music search interface for recommendations is fantastic.But then I started noticing some serious problems. Allot of songs that I wanted to download with my unlimited subscription were “Buy Only”.
For a one time monthly fee I expect that the entire library would be downloadable.Not only that but their pricing scheme is all screwed up. Below is an album by ABC, every song in the album is buy only at 99 cents. There are 9 songs. So you can pay for each song individually (Cost you $9) or you could buy the album for $9.95. Does that make sense?
![]()
(Napster View – Shows entire albulm that is buy only)
Although the service has potential I do not recommend subscribing to the service until the following changes take place:
- All songs in the library are available to be downloaded under the monthly model
- Albums should always be sold at a discount relative to buying all the songs individually (or at least it should cost the same as buying all of the tracks individually)
- Napster needs to improve the interface for mixing MP3’s you already have with songs in your Napster library. Right now its a pain to do. Under Apple Itunes purchased songs and MP3’s from your hard drive intermix seamlessly.
Looks like when the promotional period is over I might be checking out the competition.



